Freedom of speech under attack in North Carolina?
I’m interested in learning more about the incident involving a “conservative kiosk” in North Carolina, whose owner claims he is being “kicked out” of a mall because he sells “conservative” items.
With the exception of Fox News, who I consider somewhat unreliable at best, the national media has totally ignored this story. A Google search produced several blog hits and a few reports from local media, but I didn’t find many national stories.
A North Carolina NBC affiliate carried the most informative story I’ve found so far. From it, I pieced the following together.
Loren Spivack owned and operated a kiosk inside the Concord Mills Mall in Concord, North Carolina. In his kiosk, Spivack sold various items with political motivated slogans and phrases. The examples provided by the NBC station included bumper stickers with “Impeach Obama,” “Work Harder. Obama Needs the Money,” and “Al Qaeda’s favorite days: 9/11/01 and 11/4/08″.
Personally, I find the stickers pretty lame and wonder how long it would take the average American to process the significance of the “11/4/08″ date. Sure, political junkies, such as myself, recognize the date as the day Barack Obama won the election, but you want a quick response and reaction with bumper stickers, from a mass audience, and that one requires a certain level of political awareness. Regardless, Simon Property Group, which owns Concord Mills Mall, communicated with Spivack that they would allow his lease to expire on July 31, 2009. According to this report, mall management felt that items sold at the kiosk were not “neutral” enough.
This decision follows a strongly worded letter printed in the Charlotte Observer, in which a recent college graduate complained about several of the items sold at the kiosk. The letter refers to several items with “pro confederacy statements” and items that promote “racism, sexism and even slavery.”
I understand that kiosks in the South sometimes sell items containing the Confederate flag or with slogans like, “the South will rise again.” Those type of items are definitely tacky, but no one has provided examples of these items being sold at the kiosk in question. Indeed, the only three items I can find mentioned being sold at the kiosk are the three bumper stickers mentioned earlier. In my opinion, none of the bumper stickers reported by the NBC station promote racism, sexism or slavery and none of them contain “pro-Confederacy statements.”
All three stickers contain anti-Obama messages, but speaking out against this President, voicing a strongly worded opinion about his election, do not qualify as “racist” or “sexist.” Speaking out against elected officials is American as apple pie. I’ve been doing it since I was a kid.
On October 14, 2008, I posted a blog expressing concern that criticizing then candidate Obama would result in this type of reaction. In the piece, I modeled two t-shirts I bought to express my discontent with the Bush administration. During the the Bush administration, I decorated my car with several “anti-Bush” bumper stickers, including “Vote Republican, It’s Never Too Late to Return to the Dark Ages” and “F The President”. I never went anywhere without my black rubber band that said “I Did Not Vote For Bush” or my blue band that said “Count Me Blue” (as in “blue states”). I wish I could contact the college student who wrote the letter to the Charlotte newspaper complaining about the kiosk. I would like to get their opinion on my anti-Bush t-shirts, bumper stickers and rubber bracelets.
Maybe it’s the punk in me, but I’m for free speech all the time, everywhere. I did not vote for Bush and I did not vote for Obama. I think both are poor presidents and I have spent a good chunk of my time criticizing both of them. Until the suits at Simon decide to comment on this issue, we’ll never know the full story, but if what has been reported so far is true, I would suggest a boycott may be in order.



